I think that it is interesting how Vashti worships the machine as if it were her religion. The idea of it brings her comfort and happiness, just like religion does to many people today. However the machine as a religion has started to take over her life as she believes she physically cannot live without it. It has become a dominant presence in her life to the point that she listens to everything it says. She never thinks to question the machine because she has been taught to accept it. Vashti would rather live with what she knows than have to learn and accept something new.
Daily Archives: September 14, 2014
A New Form of Abstinence
When one says the word ‘abstinence,’ most of us think about high school sex ed and the concept of not engaging in sexual activity until we’ve reached a certain age, or in some cases, until we’re married. In The Machine Stops, we’re introduced to a new form of abstinence; a world in which individuals avoid any physical contact with each other. In fact on page 9, the narrator mentions that “The custom [of physical contact] had become obsolete, owing to the Machine.” This, undoubtedly raises many questions in the reader. The first being: how do they reproduce? We know that they reproduce for the protagonist herself has multiple children. So are humans artificially inseminated just like we do to cattle and swine? Second: did the people in Forster’s world forego human contact willingly? By that I mean: did they decide that the study of information superseded the basic human necessity for contact with others, or on a darker note, did the Machine decide for them? This is the most intriguing part of the story for me because the science fiction I’ve read didn’t touch on the concept of physical isolation in this way. Especially not willing and accepted isolation. The last point I want to make is a reflection of one of the first statements made in the story. On the first page, the narrator says that Vashti knows “several thousand people…human intercourse had advanced enormously.” But what does it mean that she has several thousand friends, yet is incapable of a romantic relationship, of falling in love? This, in some ways, is comparable to the person in our lifetime who has 5,000 friends on Facebook or a couple thousand followers on Instagram but only personally knows maybe a third of them. Aside from predicting quite accurately the types of technology that we would be using in the future, Forster also tackles the issues that we would inevitably face once bestowed with these tools.
Sustainability and Technology – The Machine Stops
I found that it was interesting how Vashti says at the end of the short story that ” tomorrow – some fool will start the Machine again, tomorrow” (22). She has lived in this world since she was born and believes wholeheartedly that at the end of the day technological advancement supersedes all other human desires. Our society today, or most of it at least, has the same paradigm that Vashti has. Having newer devices that facilitate our lives is always a positive enterprise to delve into. However, some balance should be added into the equation – sustainability. There should always be so conscious commitment to ensuring that what humans produce doesn’t destroy our natural resources altogether and has some sort of recycling process. Today, I went to Weeksville. A heritage sight that is affiliated to the Residential College, and essentially Goddard Hall. I went there to do some service learning and saw first-hand, not like the people that live in the Machine do, the efforts of urban agriculture and aquaponics being practiced there. There is now a movement for more locally produced food, clothes, arts etc. This shows that people in this generation are more conscious of how corporations may profit from having isolated production and assembling parts to sell products. Yet, having less mass-produced products can also be beneficial for local communities. So, after reading this story I reflected on how society is working towards more sustainable approaches to prevent us from having the Machine. I found that paradoxically we value technological advancement and we are starting to give importance to sustainability projects. So which will triumph?