Monthly Archives: November 2016

The Cost of High Expectations and its Inflation

“Everybody is expecting me to be something big… this kid is going to be very successful – it’s a possibility that you will see him in the newspapers one day.”

from Succeeding in the City

Listed as one of the key findings of the Penn study on the success of black and latino students is the universal factor of high expectations among successful minority students. I wonder if that idea may have an unexplored dark side or perhaps its value has become inflated in today’s job market.

Continue reading The Cost of High Expectations and its Inflation

“Teachers here really care”

“No one said a teacher was his favorite because she or he was easy”.
– Harper et al., 2014, p. 22

This study on black on latino male high school achievement in NYC resonated a lot due to my student teaching placement. I am in a charter high school in the Bronx that is 60% Latinx and 40% black. I am very familiar with the deficit model thinking in regards to latino and black males due to media and unfortunately adults at the school. While many teachers work extremely hard and set high expectations for their students, some I have heard say “We just have to accept that some of our kids won’t get into college”. Continue reading “Teachers here really care”

The clear box imposed by the administrative mime

I received admonishment and complaints from administrators and some colleagues who claimed that I should “be careful, this is awfully mature for sixth graders!” But we can’t truly address bullying without closely examining the language that fuels it (Krywanczyk, 2009, p. 3-4).

This is one of the biggest problems in our education system. The lack of support from the school administration, other colleagues, and even the questioning confidence in ourselves. Taboo topics keep teachers in a clear box drawn out by the administrative mime. One can can see the questions and issues students have and deal with, but psychological restrictions impede us from doing anything about it. When educators, like Mr. Krywanczyk, take the first step towards creating an open space that welcomes challenging and oh-my-goodness taboo topics that students already know and experience, they are met with resistance from other educators who are too afraid or too indifferent to start these conversations. This is not to say that there should be some restrictions in the manner that some topics are presented, especially when the students are at younger age. However, like Mr. Krywanczyk says, schools need to serve the students’ needs. This includes preparing students to combat and prevent abuse from others, from themselves, and towards others.  

Furthermore, covering topics that deal with bullying is a serious matter. For this reason, surface prevention, meaning telling our students to stop bullying is wrong without in-depth discussion of the why/how people get bullied, is negligence. Just like instruction, students need scaffolded lessons on identifying bullying, reporting it, and, hopefully, preventing it. To really attack the issue of bullying educators and administrators (including parents) need to stop walking on eggshells. Bullies and other sources of violence, racism, sexism, and abuse do not. So why should we if we are to fight them?

Creating safe spaces to challenge pressures of masculinity

“The greatest risk factor in school violence is masculinity.”

Writing about school shootings, Kimmel underscores the fact that all the school shootings in the U.S. have been committed by male students. This uniformity, Kimmel explains, cuts across all other differences among the shooters – they come from different backgrounds, such as from intact families, single-parent homes, violent homes, or what appears to be happy families. Yet, the one thing all the school shooters have in common is being male. Kimmel urges us to consider what this means about masculinity in school and how it can manifest into school violence. Continue reading Creating safe spaces to challenge pressures of masculinity

Girls Can Be Their Own Worst Enemy

“For example, Gilligan has found that the pressures of trying to succeed academically by speaking up, but also trying to be attractive to boys by staying quiet, can cause girls to silence themselves in school.”-Michelle Galley

This quote stuck with me after I finished reading Michelle Galley’s chapter on “Who am I as a learner?” Would Girls and Boys Tend to Answer Differently?  simply because this has been a common reccurence at the school where I student teach. I’ve noticed how quiet and recluse the girls are in the 7th and 8th grades, but particularly more so in 7th grade Spanish where the girls are being surrounded by loud and rowdy boys. My CT has tried to encourage and give plenty of opportunties for the girls to participate, but they seem to not be interested or are afraid of “showing off their talents” and being marked as “unattractive” to the boys.

I know I can relate to this quote as well because I did something similar when I was in 9th grade. I had a major crush on one of the football players in my English class and I tried so hard for him to notice me, but at the same time I didn’t want to come across as smart. So, I remained quiet and didn’t speak out as much because I was hoping that I would attract my crush into liking me back, of course, it completely backfired. However, I slowly realized that by the time I reached university, guys don’t really want to be with a girl who “acts stupid,” but wants a girl who is smart, confident, and assertive. I wished I had known this earlier when I was back in high school so I didn’t have to waste my time pining over a guy who never once noticed/looked at me, but on the other hand, I don’t think my 16 year old self would’ve listened to that piece of advice either.

Since I have been student teaching, I have come across many of the girls in 7th and 8th grade who have low-esteems and poor images of themselves academically. One 8th grade girl recently has accepted the title of being called an airhead amongst her classmates. I was completely shocked that this particular 8th grader would even accept this term as her label because 1. she is popular and 2. I don’t consider her an airhead at all, but someone who is a good student/person when she wants to be. So, how can we as educators prevent our students, particularly adolescent girls between the ages of 13-16, in thinking that they can’t be smart in order to attract the opposite sex?