“I don’t want to be a teenager, but I am a teenager. It’s confusing: the kids in my class are like acting like they’re adults already. Having all this Victoria’s Secret stuff, the lotions and perfume, and doing what girls do in music videos. I think that we should talk about things, learn more about ourselves. A lot of people are confused about their identities. Carmela.” (Cushman, K., & Rogers, L, 2008, 15)
This quote from Carmela about her experience resonates with me about my own middle school experience. From 5th grade in elementary school to 6th grade in middle school, there was a huge change in me. I lived a very much sheltered life and when I started middle school I was very much still “baby-ish”. I was in Girl Scouts, shopped at the Children’s Place, had a closet full of Barbie dolls and still have stuffed animals on my bed. But then, I went to my neighbor’s house one day after school, she was in 8th grade, I saw a very different picture than my own room. She had an iPod, Hollister and Abercrombie clothes, posters of guys, and most notably, I remember the Victoria Secret stuff, like Carmela mentioned. I remember thinking that was weird since it was a grown-up store. It didn’t help later that my 13-year-old neighbor thought it would be fun to show off her bras and thongs to me, things that horrified my 11-year-old self. So that day I went home, put the stuffed animals under my bed, and trashed my Barbies. Like Carmela, I didn’t want to be a teenager yet. But now that I saw what a teenager’s room looked like, I would be embarassed if anyone saw my room in it’s current state. Becoming a teenager for me was more of a requirement to fit in. I still had no idea about my identity and what I wanted during middle school. I didn’t figure all that out until high school. As teachers, we must remember that teaching our subjects is just as important as supporting our students through this period of intense change in their lives.
Hi Emily,
I really liked your anecdote about you as an 11 year old and your 13 year old neighbor. When I was reading your post I couldn’t help, but think about the movie Thirteen. I don’t know if you’ve ever seen it before, but the main character played by Evan Rachel Wood befriends the most popular girl at school named Evie who was played by Nikki Reed and when Nikki Reed’s character makes fun of how childish Evan Rachel Wood’s character dresses/acts…she immediately runs home and starts trashing her stuff animals and decides to change the look of her bedroom as well as her clothes because she realizes she wasn’t going to demand the respect from the popular Evie or fit in. Luckily, you didn’t go down a destructive path like Evan Rachel Wood’s character and realized that it wasn’t the end of the world, if you didn’t know who exactly what you were or what your identity was until much later in High School. I definitely agree with your last sentence that teachers aren’t only responsible for teaching the course content, but being a support system to our students while they are still trying to figure themselves out along with the changes. I think most teachers honestly forget why they end up being a teacher in the first place and think it is going to be easy as pie when in reality it isn’t.