“Of course, as every teacher knows, each student is an individual. Although there are many similarities that researchers have observed among students with certain defining characteristics, such as gender, it is dangerous to oversimplify the issue. Not all boys are alike, nor are all girls alike. Wilhelm and Smith claim that the battle lines in the gender war are misdrawn because there are boys and girls on both sides. They write…”We categorize for the sake of argument, clarity, and for ease of thinking, but sometimes our categories cause problems and keep us from seeing the students before us” (Galley, 91-92) / “Who am I as a learner?” Would Girls and Boys Tend to Answer Differently?
When I came to the end of this reading and read this passage I let out a huge sigh of relief. When fueling discussions like “the gender wars,” it is of the utmost importance that authors step back from the issue and consider the tangible impact that such debates have on real students. In this passage, Galley shines a light on gender as social construct, reminding her readers that although there are measurable trends related to cognitive differences and school performance according to gender, these trends shouldn’t erase the complex humanity (of which gender is only a part) of individual students whom we deal with everyday. Continue reading Reifying Socially Constructed Differences