MTA’s recent announcement that it will implement the New York Congestion Pricing program this spring faces legal pushback. The program, which decides to charge fees for vehicles entering the CBD areas in Manhattan, bothers small business owners and many others who have to visit the area frequently.
After MTA announced the expected implementation of the New York Congestion Pricing program in Spring 2024, the NYC Teachers Union and New Jersey Officials have already filed lawsuits against it, and small business owners are now joining these parties to sue MTA.
According to the MTA’s statement, the organization plans to implement the program through a 30-day testing phase. Before implementation in Spring 2024, the agency will also run a 60-day public information campaign to educate the public. The MTA board approved the initial plan of $15 and more daily tolls for vehicles entering the CBD areas, including and below 60th Street in Manhattan, between 5 a.m. and 9 p.m.
According to the MTA, setting up this fee would resolve traffic congestion in the area and reduce air pollution. MTA also aims to use the estimated fees collected from the drivers to improve its public transportation facilities, even though many, including small business owners, have yet to determine whether the facilities would be better to benefit the public.
Aiming to stop the implementation of MTA’s high tolls to enter midtown Manhattan, around two dozen small business owners gathered in front of New York City Hall on Tuesday, February 27. They signed a class action lawsuit, “New Yorkers Against Congestion Pricing,” suing MTA.
The small business owners claimed that the Congestion Pricing, also known as the Central Business District Tolling Program, would bankrupt many small businesses as they have not fully recovered from COVID-19, and the MTA only completed the shorter Environmental Assessment. They demand that MTA fulfill a more comprehensive and extended Environmental Impact Study before further implementing the Congestion Pricing Program.
Before small business owners took action, New York City’s Teachers Union and New Jersey officials sued MTA’s Congestion Pricing in January 2024, stating that it violates the consumers’ constitutional rights to bar state protectionism.

