The Visual Metaphor Project – A Poem by Skyler

Here’s a link to the film.

A. Concept and Story

The concept was born from a poem I wrote when I was 16, which expresses my depressing thoughts and feelings. I think it’s a topic actually related to everyone, about dark feelings and hard times. As for me, of course, this topic has another significant meaning. I want others to have a deeper understanding of how people with depression feel through my work, as this group of people is often misunderstood by others in daily life. There are already a lot of videos or short films released to the public, but from the perspective of a real patient, I feel many of the videos are still misinterpreting depression, which is a harrowing fact. Therefore, I want to do something for the group, more precisely to say, for us.

I’m not trying to make a film that has each scene corresponding to the imagery in each line of the poem but trying to make one that corresponds to the poem’s overall conception and emotions. In this way, this whole film is a visual metaphor for the whole poem. 

The video has two storylines: one is the character writing the poems, and the other one is the scenes she recalls when she’s writing the poem.

(The original poem and translation can be found here. If you are interested in the background when I wrote it, here is another prose written in the same period.)

B. Creation Process & Execution

I decided on the visuals I‘m going to highlight in the film based on my real experiences, and then I drew a draft of the storyboards. After determining the shooting site, I re-drew a version of detailed storyboards which basically correspond to every shot I plan to shoot (there’re a few scenes that hadn’t been drawn before shooting but I have them on my mind). The storyboards were also used as the function of a shot list and checklist on the shooting site. Inspired by the site, I also created a few new shots that were not in the original plan after the crew got there. (Storyboards can be found at the end of the documentation.)

I selected an Airbnb house as the shooting site, which had dark color composition and vintage style because these elements would fit the film’s heavy tone. And its layout generally fitted the scenes’ required setting in my storyboards. During shooting, because the site’s natural lighting was awful, I had to rely on artificial lighting which was totally artificial. I set an LED lighting tube outside the window to create a visual of the dawn and used flashlights from two cellphones to make elaborate lighting that was needed in several scenes. I also rented other two LED lighting panels in case of need but they weren’t used in the actual shooting. Because my camera operator (my only crew member for this project) barely had former experience in shooting and lighting, I needed to show her how to operate the camera and lighting equipment concretely for each shot, and then she copied my example. Though the process took a longer time than I thought, her shots gave me many surprises.  

The challenges during the shooting were mainly the battery problem. My camera only had one battery and it ran out three times during our shooting. I considered renting one more battery when mine ran out for the first time, but it was too late and there was no delivery anymore. The shooting crew (fortunately only two people including me) could only wait there till it got recharged. And sometimes the camera operator couldn’t achieve the visual effects planned in my storyboards, I just kept patient and led her to try more times to make the shots in the end. I would also adjust my way of acting based on the last footage. It was a work of practice. Moreover, there was a safety issue I forgot to consider for the bathroom scene. I arranged the scene to the end of our shooting because it was the most difficult and complex one. During the shooting, the floor got very slippery because of the water, and the camera operator needed to stand on a chair to shoot one shot. We could only make the shot as fast as possible in case of any danger. Even though, I still slipped on the floor for shooting this. I think one more assistant would be helpful for such scenes, and the crew needs to prepare our own firm ladder next time.

For the audio, I translated my poem into English to be the voice-over script and chose an Icelandic musician – Olafur Arnalds’ work to be the background music (Fyrsta – Olafur Arnalds). This music choice depends on its tone and pacing, which means its tone needs to be kind of heavy and its pacing should fit my storyboards’ pacing – their climax should basically start at the same time. The first recording of the voice-over was made before our shooting, it gave us a general idea of how long the film should be at the end. Our first recording’s left and right pans were not balanced and I adjusted them later. But in the end, due to the change in my poem’s translation, I re-recorded the voice-over after the video was basically done and tried to make the tone and intonation more proper.

The editing technique was mainly to fit the audio’s pacing and the visual’s pacing, making them harmonious together. The shots were numerous so it was a big project to make the final editing in the end. I’m glad I made it, though it really took a long time. I was already a kind of skilled editor and I didn’t use many new techniques in this video. One new strategy I used was to put different versions of clips in different tracks of video/audio on Premiere and then compare the different combinations multiple times, finally making the decision. The whole process of editing was one more valuable practice for me. 

C. Credits

I’m the director, screenwriter, and actor in this project. I’m responsible for designing all the shooting details and making artistic and technical decisions for this project.

My crew member Joy held the post of camera operator. She also contributed a lot during the shooting. I appreciated her assistance and her optimism, which really radiated me a lot. In the beginning, after we arrived at the shooting site and found that the natural lighting was really awful and couldn’t be used at all, I got kind of overwhelmed because I felt very insecure about making the entire video with artificial lighting, she encouraged me and told me there was certainly a way to work it out. Her optimism encouraged me and helped me face the shooting soon again. Even though she didn’t have much shooting experience, she never gave up and kept trying over and over again with me to get the best effects. Thanks to her, this film project could become a satisfactory work in the end. 

D. Aesthetic & Results

The shooting used Canon EOS R6, RF 24-105mm to produce this full-frame short film. The shots are mainly close-ups and medium shots, as they are “close” to the audience, which can build a connection between the character and the audience, raising the audience’s sympathy for her. Most of the close-ups are planned to be hand-held as the technique can create a sense of presence for the audience, making them better immerse in the scenes. 

For capturing the depressing emotions, I decided the environment setting needs to be dim for creating a repressive atmosphere. The overall color choice is also cold and dark for fitting the concept and story. Considering cinematography, our costume choice needs to have a little contrast to help the character stand out from the scenes. That’s why the costume is a white dress. The dark green and white work together, helping create a sorrowful tone.

For addressing the character’s mental problem, the outside of the window should be bright and the inside room where the character is living should be dark in the film’s design. In this way, the film can indicate that there is no difference between the outside day and night for the protagonist who’s mostly living in her inner world, showing that she’s shutting herself down in the room and feels the darkness is the only safe place for her.

I think the aesthetics of this short film are successful as it received plenty of positive comments. Though I would like to keep both two versions of having subtitles and no subtitles, for the reason that I always feel the subtitles somehow disturb the visual, in another sense, I admit the subtitles can help the audience to synthesize the word and image on their mind.

My inspiration is related to my own experience and my former works that explore similar topics.

 

Storyboards:

Visual Metaphor Proposal

I.  Project Title (tentative)

My sorrow is not spurting out like Pompeii’s fire

II. Crew Members

Skyler Liu, Joy Zhu

III.  Concept | Storyline

We are going to use the English version of a poem written by Skyler as the script for the voice-over (the whole poem can be found below). The poem is about the oppressive thoughts and feelings of a person with depression. The original poem has five paragraphs but we will only choose two or three of them for this project considering the time length. 

In our conception, the video wouldn’t be telling a story with a clear beginning, middle, and ending which is common to see. It will be an abstract art film to convey emotions. Instead of shooting a video with every scene that directly corresponds to every imagery appearing in the poem, we would make a video parallel with the voice-over in their superficial content, but from another perspective, they would work together to convey similar emotions. Therefore, we would focus on shooting several scenes that reveal the daily state of a person with depression: sometimes she’s in a fugue state, sometimes she’s staring out of the window, sometimes she’s curling up at the corner, sometimes she’s lying on the floor…etc. In this way, the whole video will be a visual metaphor for the poem. 

We will mainly experiment with color choice (in both production and post-production periods), spot setting, sound, and lighting, to create an oppressive atmosphere. The color choice includes two parts. In production, the color of the actor’s clothes and spot setting will matter to us. As the video’s tone is cold and oppressive, the main color would be cold and dark. This color choice will also be presented in the post-production. A piece of background music with a heavy tone will also help our visual metaphor to be more powerful. (There are more details about lighting in the execution plan.)

The poem:

我的悲伤不是喷薄而出如同庞贝的火,       
它用风和雨和梦的姿态将我融化。
我融化,如同蜡烛,
灯芯把挣扎的心系在躯干上。
My sorrow is not spurting out like Pompeii’s fire,
It melts me with the gesture of wind and rain and dream.
I melt, like a candle,
The struggling heart is tied to the body by a wick.

我的声音滴落,缄默在风里。
阵雨向寂静里堆满回声,把所有回应的通道占领。
而梦缠绵总也不离去,
冰凉的手像雾气覆盖我的眼睛。
My voice dripped, fading away with the wind.
The rain filled silence with echoes, occupying all the channels for a response.
And dreams would not leave,
Cold hands are like fog covering my eyes.

我遂滴落了我的骨骼与血肉,自由与魂灵。
Then I dripped my flesh and bones, freedom and soul.

七月的房间里不只住着流火的幽灵,
它挤满了压抑的尖叫,和蜷缩的影。
没有门和窗,
悲伤以一位老者的形象蹒跚徘徊在黑暗里。
There are not only ghosts of Antares living in the room of July,
It’s packed with the repressed scream, and huddled shadow.
No doors nor window,
Sorrow lingers in the dark as the figure of an old man.

他说,死去的人生活在灰烬里,
光阴踏在他们的眼睑上。
而你,
你是那颗,被判处了极刑的烧焦的星星。
He says, the dead are living in the ashes,
Time steps on their eyelids.
And you,
You are the one, burnt star, which was sentenced to Death.

Written by 刘秩靖 (Skyler Liu), 2016

IV. Execution Plan

We will rent a Sony FS5 as the main shooting equipment, a tripod to help with shooting, a Tascam for sound recording, and lighting equipment will be crucial since the location we choose is mainly inside. We will book a house with suitable settings in both colors and the style of interior design from Airbnb to be our shooting spot, and we will make it a kind of empty space in some scenes to help the despairing atmosphere more powerful. Also, we may make the inside not clearly recognizable by day or night. In this way, the video can indicate that there is no difference between the outside day and night for the protagonist who’s mostly living in her inner world.

Our main challenge comes from lighting because it will mostly shoot inside. To make the lighting more successful at conveying emotion, we will go beforehand to examine the shooting site and rehearse how the natural light may work and how to use the lighting equipment.

Our work is divided as below:

  • Director: Skyler 
  • Actor: Skyler
  • Rehearsal position actor: Joy
  • Voice actor: Undecided (we are going to record both of us and another male reading the poem and choose the one with better effect)
  • Camera operator:  Joy
  • Lighting technician: Joy
  • Editor: Skyler
  • Assistant editor: Joy

V. Storyboard Draft

VI. Gantt Chart

Task Owner Start Date Due Date Duration PCT of Task Complete
Proposal and storyboards draft Skyler, Joy 11.22 11.25 4 days 10%
Voice-over Skyler, Joy, another male actor 11.28 11.28 1 day  20%
Completed storyboards  Skyler 11.30 12.4 5 days 35%
Spot Choice Skyler, Joy 12.2 12.4 3 days 40%
Shooting Skyler, Joy 12.5 12.5 1 day 70%
First Editing Skyler 12.5 12.7 2 days 90%
Final Editing Skyler, Joy 12.8 12.10 2 days 100%

 

Innovative Narrative Approach

Him and Her, 1968-2008 (2008), Video Installation, Candice Breitz

This work is divided into two parts. The “Her” is played by Meryl Streep, and the “Him” is played by Jack Nicholson. Each part is divided into 7 small screens, playing the scenes of different characters played by the two veteran actors in different movies, and there are dialogues between them.

In terms of the form of installation art, Him and Her is played in two connected rooms. Videos in both rooms are edited very smoothly. The characters do not only correspond with their dialogues, but also with plot connections, even with their eye expressions and moving directions. For example, when Nicholson on the above screen says something, the lunatic he played in The Shining below would laugh, and the other Nicholson would applaud. The artist Breitz searched for the materials she needed in many films that these two old veteran actors participated in, and then conducted re-creation and re-editing. In her re-creation, the audience can piece together the information from these crossover screens to a new plot, a new story, and a new theme.

At the same time, the clips of the male and female protagonists are removed from their original movie plots. The artist removes all the background behind them and turns them into a unified black, so the audience can only focus on their looks and talks, postures and dressing, and then give a reasonable explanation based on this information.

In addition, the special perspective on the two actors and visual effects make people feel that Streep and Nicholson in the scenes are not themselves, but many ordinary people, some of them look like teachers, lawyers, underworlds, or madmen, some of them are laughing, some are crying; they look like people with mental illness who come to the counselor for help, and every audience is a psychiatrist who listens to their stories. Therefore, through this form, Breitz’s installation can be regarded as a humanity observation room magnified by screens. The materials are selected from the film material library, allowing the audience to see different types of emotions including anxiety, happiness, and disappointment, grievance, anger, confusion, etc. As a result, the content of such a work gradually deviates from the superficial meaning of Hollywood stars, and gradually touches the content of the emotional expression of ordinary people.

This method of drawing materials based on big data, looking for new creative materials in the ready-made products of culture and art, and secondly assembling and creating art also implies our current era and the time we live in. Now, when we watch movies on the Internet, we can pause, take screenshots, play backwards, repeat, and fast forward without following the movie screening rules. This is the change in watching movies brought to us by our modern lifestyle. So, what is time, what is content, and what is narrative is no longer fixed in the lifestyle of modern people, nor is it completely determined by the film director, but depends on the audience in front of the computer screen. Him and Her embodies a kind of challenge and rebellion from the audience against the status of the sole creator, as well as the subjective manipulation of the traditional narrative approach.

The Memory Soundscape Project

A. Concept

Work Title: Mom’s Cooking

I chose the first memory that occupies my mind when it comes to the word “sonic memory”, which I think is the deepest impression of sound in my memory. It is the sounds I heard when my mom cooked in the kitchen when I was a kid. It includes the sound of gas, oil boiling, ingredients entering the pot and food getting stirred in the pot, etc. It’s a noisy mix of sounds, but it’s about life, and my expectation for lunch as a kid, so it is a kind of warm and pleasant sounds.

In the beginning, I just planned to remake the actual sounds of my memory but later I realized, another important aspect of the memory might not stand out to the audience in this way, which is the feeling when I listened to the sounds in my childhood. I remembered the way I felt the sounds. I often imagined them to be a song when all the different sounds during cooking came together, but somehow it was harmonious and pleasant. Therefore, I decided to make this memory soundscape combine the actual sounds of cooking and the pleasant feeling when I listened to them by editing them to be a piece of music related to my memory.

B. Process

I have recorded almost every sound during cooking lunch, but I didn’t use all of them because the length of this soundscape is only one minute, and including all the details of the actual sounds wouldn’t help the audience catch the feeling of my memory. In the end, I chose the sound of the gas stove, the sound of the kitchen ventilator, the sound of oil boiling, the sound of ingredients entering the pot, and the sound of food getting stirred in the pot, as I think they are the most impressive sounds that stand out in my memory during my mother’s cooking. 

While recording, I held the TASCAM to be as close as possible to the stove (but definitely from a safe distance) because I wanted my audience to feel that the sounds are close, as you are hearing them right in front of you, and they are so close to your life as well. I encountered the problem of having too much noise like wind sound in my recording. The solution was just paying more awareness of things in the environment that might make noise then recording several times to have the best quality of needed sounds as I could. 

The beginning section of my project is imitating the actual sounds of cooking. After selecting specific recordings that are mentioned above, I combined them together to make them sound like the real cooking process even though the length was reduced a lot compared to reality. The main method was emphasizing the “key sound” – the sound of ingredients entering the pot, by repeating and manipulating this part. Because the sound is the most vivid and impressive part of my memory.

The other section of my project is creating music from the actual cooking sounds. During editing, the most challenging part was selecting the proper effects for making the piece of music. I tried plenty of different effects and finally decided on the notch filter. It has multiple pre-settings including “A and E minor”, “C major”, and so on, which can transform the corresponding pitch in your recording to the exact note-like sound in music. To make the “music” sounds more pleasant and less monotonous, I created multiple tracks in Audition and set each of them in different minor or major – because the average pitch of the cooking sounds was kind of high, I mainly chose A and E minor and E minor chords work together to make the music sounds harmonious, fitting the music I felt in my memory. Also, there were reversing effects and pans shifting in the middle section of the music to create a more abundant auditory experience.

I also learned a lot of other techniques while doing the editing, such as how to make noise reduction and the transition of audios. Besides the techniques, I think the most important thing is how to consider my work from the audience’s perspectives and make all the complex audios sound harmonious together as a whole soundscape work in the end. 

C. Conclusion

As mentioned by Jingtian, if I had more time, I would record more cooking sounds that including thin rubbing sounds, for making a string type of melody in the music section. Because now my project mainly has the percussion type of melody, which might sound a little monotonous. 

D.  Image of Audition

Here‘s the link for this memory soundscape.

Capstone Research: Literature

  1. McClain, Shilo T., Digital Storytelling: The Narrative Power of Visual Effects in Film. The MIT Press
  2. Wexner, L. B. (1954). The degree to which colors (hues) are associated with mood-tones. Journal of Applied Psychology, 38(6), 432–435. 
  3. Tarvainen, J., Westman, S., & Oittinen, P. (2015). The way films feel: Aesthetic features and mood in film. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 9(3), 254–265.
  4. Lidwell, William. How Colors Affect You: What Science Reviews. University of Houston.
  5. Anderson, Joseph D.. Anderson, Barbara Fisher. “Film Lighting and Mood”. Moving Image Theory: Ecological Consideration, 152-162. SIU Press. 2007.
  6. Harnsberger, Jessica. “Shadows and Darkness: Learning to Triumph over Human Weakness”. The Victorian Web. Brown University. 2004.

    to be updated