Week 1: “The Machine Stops” Reading Reflection- Ying Chen

The short story “The Machine Stops” by E.M. Forster written during the early 20th century addresses the negative role of technology in our lives and the way modern people interact with them. Forster developed this science fictional world of a destroyed Earth where there is a disconnected relation between a mother and son. Throughout the story, the machine played an immense role in the trajectory of humanity and the relationships between people. Although the story is unrealistic and is dramatized, Forster was able to foresee the possible danger of technology such as the issue of human dependency on technology.

The story is indeed a society where everything is controlled by machines and human was heavily depended on it. The author began the story by leading the readers into this world where individuals live and function within a cell. This can be symbolism for how our society is becoming more homogeneous. An example can be the job industry where individuals work in an office building or factories and work in their own little workplace that looks and function just like a cell. But the more serious problem of this story is the human dependency on machines. Vashati, the mother is being characterized as someone who is completely living off of the machines. This machine allows individuals to communicate but without being face-to-face or being able to touch each other. You can see this as a modern communication tool like Wechat, Facebook etc. Vashati’s son, Kuno, on the other hand, doesn’t favor the machine at all. He said to his mother “you talk as if God made the machine”, while his mother says to him “One mustn’t say anything against the Machine,” (Forster).  Her response clearly states not only the importance of the Machine but that we should obey it. Also, Forster capitalized the letter “m” whenever the “Machine” is mentioned. This shows off its significance and how it is held at such high level, that it is worthy of praise. In fact, the machine is far more powerful even though it is us that we created them. Like Kuno says “it is we who are dying, and that down here the only thing that really lives is the Machine” (15). 

My take away from this story is that people today are obsessed with technology, whether it is a smartphone or computers. We live in a world where technology is rapidly advancing making it a necessity to our lives as if it was our way of breathing. It can be seen as a lesson for human advancement in technology and anyone who is building a new technology should reconsider before building it because it can cause these complications that can possibly disturb humanity. 

Week 1: Response to “The Machine Stops” by E.M. Forster- Cara Chang

E.M. Forster’s “The Machine Stops” closely relates to our society today. In the short story, what is left of their society is a broken world controlled by one singular machine. As our own world progresses into this new era filled with the internet and social media, people are slowly becoming more glued to their cellular devices and less involved with other people. This can be compared to the story, as Vashti refuses to see Kuno because they can easily communicate with each other through the Machine. I personally thought that the specific part where Kuno longs to see his mother can be very relatable to kids in our own world. Vashti thinks that it is enough to only talk to her son through a mechanical device, whereas Kuno demands a face to face interaction, even though it is highly risky,  because their society took advantage of The Machine so heavily, leaving their own world to rot. Like many children to their parents in reality, many kids feel the longing need to see their family, but only to have their parents give the excuse that they must work, and that communication can be easily done through any video call app, such as FaceTime or Skype. In the story, the reader can see how in the end, as people take advantage of The Machine, the human race deteriorates and the world ends up crumbling apart. If we ourselves cannot control the way we utilize the advantageous tools we have, we are set up for the same fate. A similar example can be the way people rely on cars that consume gas to get from place to place. We consciously send gasses into the air, depleting our ozone layer one step at a time. The same can be applied for factories and any other unit that releases toxic gas in the air. The way that our society uses the internet/electronic devices to complete everyday tasks can lead humans to become dependent on the internet, rather than only referring to it as an assisting aide. Many things that come with the age of the internet come with many advantages yes, but if used in a manipulative manner that controls everyone’s lives, it can very easily lead to the world’s destruction, relating to the same ending as “The Machine Stops”. 

Week 1: Response to “The Machine Stops” E.M. Foerster – Hannah Kasak-Gliboff

Machine and technology exist for the most part to improve lives and diminish the hardships or discomfort of completing tasks. In “The Machine Stops” Foerster invents a world in which people have delegated all tasks and reduced all interactions to the Machine. Vashti’s thoughts and dialogue demonstrate an ironic contrast between the uneventfulness of her life and the urgency with which they seek to come up with ideas. Meanwhile, anything that might inspire ideas is hurriedly dismissed. While we use machinery to reduce the effort of completing tasks and leave ourselves time to develop ideas, the development of ideas requires interaction with others in a way that the Machine destroyed. The value and importance of machinery and media is not just the interactiveness between the user and the media but the interaction it facilitates with other people. The story is a grim cautionary tale about human dependence on machinery and a statement that connection, communications, and free thought are put at risk by a life of pure comfort and ease. In relation to this class, the story emphasizes the importance of interpersonal interaction and communication through media, rather than mere interaction with media itself. 

Week 1: Response to “The Machine Stops” E.M Forster – Xavier Juhala

This reading was an interesting take on what has become our societies dependence on technology to perform even the most basic human tasks. I think that the fact that Forster is illustrating this in such a way; by showing us this in a dystopian type of story enhances the argument that society is heading towards total dependence on technology. The fact that it is a story makes it interesting to read and puts the argument in a space separate from our own so that we are able to see the truth in it. I think if this was just a rhetorical piece it wouldn’t be nearly as effective as it could easily be dismissed as over the top and just an article trying to scare people. Vashti’s character accurately shows in today’s world our human interactions are becoming diminished as rather than living in the moment we become absorbed in the world within our devices, this is represented in her not even wanting to see her son. Even seeing her son becomes a hassle for her as it seems she would rather stay in her home, absorbed in her comfortable protected world. The “machine” represents this world which we are heading towards and I think that this story serves as a powerful warning that we shouldn’t forget about our human needs and emotions and that we should be cautious on over-reliance of our technology. 

Week 1 : Response to “The Machine Stops” E.M. Forster – Samantha Cui

I was fascinated by Forster’s reading “The Machine Stops”. While reading it, I thought it to be futuristic considering the time it was published and it felt like it was really close to everyday life nowadays. Especially for the first part when Kuno and Vashti were having a conversation through the machine. While reading this part, I thought of it to be a useful tool. But then I realized that we do have this “machine” now, facetime on our iPhone. It appears that Vashti is extremely reliant to this machine. Forster writes this reflecting on the issue that someday people will be “controlled” that they can’t live a day without the machine. Even this story was written and published over 100 years, but it is scaringly similar to present day. It shows the ugliness of how some people even choose technology over their family and friends. It emphasizes the damage and changes machines would bring. Living in a time where we are surrounded by machine, it really makes you think a lot.