By Rick Valachovic, DMD, MPH, Clinical Professor and Executive Director of the NYU Dentistry Center for Oral Health Policy and Management
Trust is the foundation of effective health care, yet dentistry faces unprecedented challenges to its professional reputation. When headlines spotlight a child’s death during dental sedation, a practitioner charged with Medicaid fraud, or contentious scope-of-practice disputes that limit access to care, these isolated incidents cast shadows across the entire profession. The damage extends beyond the individuals involved in that it erodes the collective trust that dentists have cultivated through years of dedicated patient care and professional integrity.
Today bad news travels quickly, and Americans’ views of professionals are declining. According to Gallup’s 2024 Honesty and Ethics poll, nurses, who have long topped the poll as the most trusted professionals, earned a positive rating from only 76% of respondents — 9 points lower than in 2019. Positive ratings of physicians fell nine points over the same period to a meager 56%, and at 59%, dentists did not fare much better. Public perceptions of the health professions rose during the COVID-19 pandemic but have since declined to all-time lows, especially among non-college graduates.
To withstand these trends, dentists must possess more than clinical expertise and managerial competencies. We need leadership grounded in the recognition that dentistry must operate as a moral community, where ethical principles, patient advocacy, and social responsibility form the foundation of professional practice.
Defining Our Moral Community
A moral community is a group of individuals bound by a shared commitment to ethical standards and a collective sense of responsibility toward the welfare of others. Through shared values and mutual accountability, this community has the capacity to influence members’ actions. In health care, those fundamental values include a commitment to providing our patients with patient-centered care, but they don’t stop there. The American College of Dentists (ACD) has historically emphasized that dentists have a social responsibility to address access and equity challenges for vulnerable populations as well. Those of us who are dental educators must also ensure that these values inform how we mentor future generations, engage with our communities, and shape the future of the profession.
Persistent and Emerging Challenges
As members of the dental profession, we are obligated to do no harm, to act in the best interests of the patient, and to respect the autonomy and dignity of each individual. Today a host of contemporary challenges undermine our ability to meet those obligations.
- The longstanding tension between the primacy of our ethical obligations to patients and the pressures of self-interest in the marketplace is being exacerbated by the growing influence of private equity in dentistry. According to a study by the American Dental Association Health Policy Institute, the portion of U.S. dentists affiliated with private equity increased from 6.6% in 2015 to 12.8% in 2021, and the number of private equity transactions rose five-fold over the same period. How these acquisitions will affect the quality of patient care has yet to be documented, but dentists will need to keep their ethical obligations in front of mind as the economic pressures on them increase.
- Advances in technology also require that we adopt an ethical lens in evaluating whether the latest procedure or test is appropriate for our patients. The use of high-dose radiographs with children, dental implants when alternative treatments are available, or crowns on healthy teeth to accommodate the quest for a perfect smile all entail a risk of harm and pose moral questions for practicing dentists.
- Persistent disparities in access to dental care and oral health outcomes present another significant moral challenge, calling us to address the larger systemic issues that affect patient care. Public health measures such as community water fluoridation may no longer be an available tool for improving the oral health of those who lack regular access to dental care. Changes in how immigration laws are enforced are also raising troubling patient-advocacy questions for dentists and their colleagues in the other health professions, whose places of works have traditionally been protected from interference by immigration enforcement personnel.
- Concurrently, programs established to dismantle the barriers that prevent underrepresented groups from entering the health professions may see their government funding eliminated. Given what we know about the value of culturally concordant care to the health and well-being of our patients, our community has a moral responsibility to devise alternative strategies for continuing this urgent work.
The updated ACD Ethics Handbook for Dentistry provides essential resources to support ethical decision-making in the face of these and other challenges. While not addressing the issues above directly, the handbook’s guidelines are useful in navigating them. For example, the section on informed consent advises us to go beyond what is legally required to include “[u]nbiased presentation of all reasonable alternatives and consequences, including costs and the probability of outcomes” and to communicate with patients “on a level assuring comprehension.” Such guidance gets to the heart of how we can act in the best interests of our patients.
The Role of Dental Educators
As members of a moral community, all members of our profession should commit to lifelong learning, humility, and service, but those of us in dental education have an additional obligation: to inculcate future dentists with the values that define dentistry as a moral community. In so doing, dental educators fulfill their fundamental role as stewards—ensuring that the profession remains true to its ethical commitments and moral foundation.
Mentoring is a vital part of this stewardship, as it enables educators to impart the ethical values and responsibilities of the profession to the next generation. So are leadership development programs such as the NYU Dentistry Leadership Portfolio, which not only teaches the technical and managerial aspects of leadership but also emphasizes the importance of character, ethics, and moral responsibility. Such efforts can foster a more empathetic and socially responsible workforce dedicated to providing equitable care for all.
Leadership as a Moral Imperative
Addressing the challenges facing our profession and our patients will require leadership — not just from academic dentists but from everyone in our profession who is committed to improving oral health and shaping the next generation of dental professionals. As stewards of the profession, we must ensure that dentistry remains a moral community—one that is grounded in ethical principles and dedicated to serving the needs of our patients and society at large. By upholding the pillars of the ACD—ethics, professionalism, leadership, and excellence—we can bolster, and where needed, rebuild the public’s trust in our profession and ensure that it continues to thrive, not only as a clinical discipline but as a community of care committed to the well-being of all.